A release plan is the sequence of places where a film is allowed to play. For decades after the Supreme Court's 1948 Paramount decision, a set of antitrust decrees told certain studios which sequences were forbidden. Those decrees are gone. What remains are contracts, theater policies, and the entry rules of awards that still care about a theatrical week. If you want to understand why one streaming title books cinemas and another does not, start with that history and then read the current prize rules. They do not match each other.

What the Supreme Court and the decrees actually forbade

In 1938 the Justice Department sued eight motion-picture companies, alleging a conspiracy to control the business through distribution and theater ownership. The defendants included Paramount, Twentieth Century-Fox, Loew's, RKO, Warner Bros., Columbia, Universal, and United Artists. The district court found a conspiracy to fix prices and to monopolize distribution and exhibition. The Supreme Court sustained those findings in United States v. Paramount Pictures, Inc., 334 U.S. 131 (1948). Each defendant later signed a consent decree.

The Antitrust Division's public history of the case lists what changed. Five defendants that owned theaters had to divest distribution or the theaters, and those defendants could not both distribute films and own theaters without court approval. The Court and the decrees also barred practices the government had attacked: block booking, which bundled several films into one theater license; circuit dealing, which licensed every theater in a circuit in one agreement; resale price maintenance, which set minimum ticket prices; and overbroad clearances, meaning exclusive licenses drawn too wide across a territory.

The Division's review page, updated August 7, 2020, describes an industry those orders no longer match in the way they did in 1948. The Paramount defendants do not own a significant number of theaters. Multiplexes replaced single-screen palaces. And the Division notes that after a theater run, people can watch films on cable, broadcast television, DVD, and streaming services that did not exist when the decrees were written. The review asked the public whether the decrees still protected competition. Comments closed in 2018.

The court ended the decrees, with one delay

On August 7, 2020, the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York granted the government's motion. The order terminates the decrees effective immediately, except for a two-year sunset on the bans against block booking and circuit dealing. The government had asked for that sunset after public comments, so theaters would have a transition before those two provisions disappeared. The remainder of the decree structure did not stay in place as a federal window law.

Nothing in that order writes a 17-day, 45-day, or 90-day gap between a cinema and a streaming app. Anyone who quotes a universal "window" as if it were still a consent-decree number is quoting a contract or a custom, and they should name the contract. Studios and theaters can still negotiate exclusivity. Antitrust law, including the Paramount precedent itself, still exists. The specific injunctions in those decrees do not.

Prize rules recreated a theatrical test the decrees no longer impose

The Academy's special rules for Best Picture at the 99th Oscars require a qualifying theatrical run. For the 2026 eligibility year, the picture must play for paid admission in a commercial theater in one of six U.S. metro areas for at least seven consecutive days, in one venue, at least three times a day, with at least one screening between 6 p.m. and 10 p.m. The metros are Los Angeles County, New York City's five boroughs, a defined Bay Area, Chicago's Cook County, Dallas and Tarrant counties, and Atlanta's Fulton County. The film has to be advertised in the ordinary way and meet the general entry rules.

Best Picture adds an expanded run: nine more markets from the Academy's list of the top 50 U.S. markets, for at least ten markets total, at least seven days in each with at least one show a day. Those days need not be consecutive. The expanded run has to fall within 45 days before or after the qualifying run. If it spills past December 31, 2026, it still has to finish within 45 days or by January 21, 2027, whichever is earlier. Missing that window can cost a nomination. The film must also meet two of the four Representation and Inclusion Standards, filed on the RAISE form by a company representative. Only a confirmed representative of the distributor or the production company named in the legal billing may submit for Best Picture.

That is a release strategy written as an eligibility rule. A film that never books those theaters never enters, no matter how many people watch it at home.

Streaming before the qualifying run can end a different Oscar path

International Feature has its own sequence. For the 99th awards, a film on the country-selection path must first be released theatrically in the country or region of origin, no earlier than October 1, 2025, and no later than September 30, 2026, for at least seven consecutive days in one commercial venue, for the profit of the producer and the exhibitor. The Academy also allows that seven-day run outside the country of origin, as long as it is outside the United States and its territories. The film does not have to open in the United States at all for this category.

Then the rules list what ruins the sequence. A nontheatrical public exhibition before the qualifying theatrical release makes the film ineligible. The list includes broadcast and cable, pay-per-view and video on demand, DVD and streaming, airline exhibition, and internet transmission. A global streaming debut that lands before the qualifying cinema week is not a clever workaround. Under this paragraph it is a disqualification, if the film is seeking this award on these rules.

There is a second door. A film can qualify by winning a listed festival prize instead of, or as the rules structure it, as an alternative qualifying criterion. The Academy's May 1, 2026 rules announcement names the qualifying festivals for the 99th Oscars: Berlin's Golden Bear for Best Film, Busan's Best Film Award, Cannes' Palme d'Or, Sundance's World Cinema Grand Jury Prize, Toronto's Platform Award, and Venice's Golden Lion. Winning one of those does not erase the dialogue, production, and advertising requirements in the special rules. It is a path onto the list, not a pass around the rest of the document.

The Directors Guild draws the opposite line on simultaneity

DGA theatrical-feature entries for the 79th awards also want seven paid days in Los Angeles or New York during 2026. They then say what the Academy's Best Picture rules do not say in the same clause: day-and-date exhibition, theatrical and any other platform at the same time, is not eligible. A pre-theatrical showing on free television, pay cable, the internet, DVD, or another system in the continental United States is not eligible either.

Read those two PDFs side by side and the strategy stops being a vibe. A company can book the Academy's ten markets, meet the three-showings-a-day test, and still be out of the DGA theatrical feature award if the film hits a streaming service on the same day it hits the cinema. A company can keep a clean theatrical exclusive long enough for the DGA and still miss Best Picture if it never completes the expanded ten-market run inside the 45-day collar. Neither document cares about a leaderboard of hours watched.

What a viewer can check without a studio org chart

Look up the dated rules for the prize the headline mentions, and look up whether a decree is being cited that the Southern District of New York ended in 2020. Then separate three dates that press releases like to blur: the first paid cinema show, the first day the film can be streamed, and the deadline on the entry form. If a story calls a plan "the window" without saying whose contract or whose rulebook, it has skipped the only part you can verify.

Release plans will keep moving, because they are deals. The documents above are public, and they are specific. Use the specific ones.

Sources