A profile page and a news report can name the same person and still have different jobs. The profile is a standing description: credits, roles, and the parts of a life that reliable sources have treated as part of the public record. The news report is a dated account of something that just happened, or of a claim that something happened. When a site uses one URL for both jobs, readers lose the date, and the person on the page loses the difference between a filmography and a rumor.

Wikipedia's biographies-of-living-persons policy is not a statute, and it binds Wikipedia editors rather than every publisher. It is still one of the few public, detailed standards for how a reference page about a living person should behave. The Society of Professional Journalists' code, revised October 4, 2026, is the parallel document for people who publish news. Reading them together shows the split.

What a reference page is for

Wikipedia's policy says material about living people, on any page, has to be written with care for verifiability, a neutral point of view, and the ban on original research. Biographies should be conservative and should consider privacy. The nutshell line is blunt: Wikipedia is an encyclopedia, not a tabloid, and it is not supposed to be the main vehicle for spreading titillating claims. The burden of evidence sits with the editor who adds or restores the material.

Tone is specified. Write cautiously, without understatement or overstatement. Document what reliable secondary sources have published, and in some cases what the subject has published about themselves. Do not hang contentious labels on people unless reliable sources commonly use those labels. Do not give a small minority of sources the whole page. Praise and criticism can both appear if they are sourced, responsible, and not given disproportionate space.

That is a profile. It can be updated. It should not read like a feed.

What gets removed, and how fast

Contentious material about a living person that is unsourced or poorly sourced is supposed to be removed immediately, without waiting for a talk-page argument. The policy says this applies whether the material is negative, positive, neutral, or merely questionable, and whether it sits in a biography or in some other article. Tabloid journalism alone is not enough to add a challenged claim. If the material is both verifiable and worth including, the policy says, it will have shown up in more reliable sources.

Self-published sources are out as evidence about a living person, unless the subject wrote them. That includes books, blogs, podcasts, and social-network posts. A newspaper column that the paper edits can be different from a reader comment. Reader comments are never acceptable sources under this policy. A press release or personal site can be used only inside narrow limits: it is not unduly self-serving or exceptional, it does not make claims about other people, it does not make claims about events the subject was not part of, its authenticity is not in real doubt, and the article is not built mostly out of it.

A profile that copies a publicist's release into the biography and presents it as the life of the person has failed that test. The release can be a source for a non-exceptional detail the subject is in a position to know. It cannot be the page.

Allegations, denials, and people who are not famous

On public figures, the policy expects a crowd of reliable sources and tells editors to document what those sources say. An allegation belongs if it is noteworthy, relevant, and documented by multiple reliable third parties. If you cannot find those sources, leave it out. The policy's own examples are useful because they are about wording. "Had a messy divorce" fails if the divorce is unimportant or if "messy" is the writer's adjective. "Divorced" is the sourced fact, if the fact matters. An affair allegation that several major papers have published, and that is denied, belongs as an allegation, not as a finding that the affair happened. If the subject has denied it, the denial goes in too.

People who are relatively unknown get a tighter page. Someone notable for one or two events should not have every detail of those events rehearsed, even when a source exists. The policy is especially firm about victims: do not extend their exposure past what the subject needs, and do not write in a way that continues the harm.

A news report can, and sometimes should, publish an allegation that a profile should not yet absorb. The report has a date, a response, and a corrections line. The profile that absorbs the allegation on day one, before the response exists, becomes a permanent version of a temporary claim. Wikipedia's policy also warns against circular reporting: a claim starts on the wiki, a weak source repeats it, and the wiki cites the weak source. Entertainment sites invent the same loop when a profile quotes a blog that quoted the profile.

What the news ethics code adds

SPJ's code asks journalists to verify before publishing, to use original sources, to correct the record through the life of a story, and to label opinion and analysis. It says never to publish fabricated material that could be confused with reality, and to label illustrations and reenactments. It says to weigh the long reach and permanence of publication, and to remember that private people have a greater claim to control information about themselves than public figures and others who seek attention. Legal access to a document is not the same as an ethical reason to publish it.

Those lines describe a news story's duties. They also explain why a news story should stay a news story. The dated article can be corrected in place, with a note that says what changed. A profile that silently rewrites itself leaves no trail. SPJ asks that corrections be explained. A biography page that wants the same trust needs a visible history or a visible note when a contested personal claim changes.

The code says to distinguish news from advertising and to label sponsored content. A profile written in the voice of a publicity bio, with no byline and no date, fails that distinction even if every credit in it is true. Credits can be accurate and the page can still be an ad.

A practical split for this site and for any other

Use the article URL for a reported development: a tour, a case, a premiere, a statement. Put the date on it. Name the document or the person who spoke. If the status is disputed, say what is known and what the subject said in response. Keep that page stable in the sense that corrections are visible, not in the sense that the words never change.

Use a profile, if you have one, for orientation. Filmography, confirmed names, and links out to the reported pieces. Do not let the top of the profile become a stack of unsourced relationship claims. Do not let a decade-old controversy occupy the lead after years of later, sourced work, unless the later sources still treat it as the center of the life. Wikipedia's balance rule is the right instinct even for publishers who are not on Wikipedia: recent events do not automatically own the page.

If you are the person on the page and something is wrong, the useful request is specific. Which sentence, which source, what the correction should say. A demand to delete a sourced, relevant fact because it is unwelcome is a different request from a demand to fix a sentence that has no source. SPJ's code tells newsrooms to correct real errors and, read alongside the living-person policy, not to treat a subject's dislike as proof that a well-documented fact must vanish.

None of this is legal advice about defamation or privacy in your state. It is a description of two published standards and of the mess that follows when a site ignores the difference between them.

Sources